4 another detail from comments (as some users have noted the site might affect the possible methods of resolution)
source | link

I am selling used textbooks online in a Facebook buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book, which I had listed for $50 OBO ("or best offer"). I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since they said they would pay $60, I would prefer for them to honour that pledge? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

I am selling used textbooks online in a buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book, which I had listed for $50 OBO ("or best offer"). I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since they said they would pay $60, I would prefer for them to honour that pledge? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

I am selling used textbooks online in a Facebook buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book, which I had listed for $50 OBO ("or best offer"). I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since they said they would pay $60, I would prefer for them to honour that pledge? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

3 added description from comment, since the wording is probably relevant
source | link

I am selling used textbooks online in a buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book, which I had listed for $50 OBO ("or best offer"). I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since they said they would pay $60, I would prefer for them to honour that pledge? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

I am selling used textbooks online in a buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book. I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since they said they would pay $60, I would prefer for them to honour that pledge? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

I am selling used textbooks online in a buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book, which I had listed for $50 OBO ("or best offer"). I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since they said they would pay $60, I would prefer for them to honour that pledge? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

2 edited body
source | link

I am selling used textbooks online in a buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book. I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since this is basically a bidding auctionthey said they would pay $60, I would prefer for them to pay the $60honour that pledge? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

I am selling used textbooks online in a buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book. I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since this is basically a bidding auction, I would prefer for them to pay the $60? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

I am selling used textbooks online in a buy and sell group. Two people contacted me within a minute apart to buy the same book. I messaged back asking them both if they would pay more than my asking price of $50, since they had both messaged at the same time (I would have sold it to the person who messaged first if they had been farther apart).

One person replied back immediately, saying they would pay $60 for it, but no more than that. The exact conversation:

Me: "Would you be willing to pay more than $50?"

Them: "I can do $60! ... But if they do any higher I'll pass."

The other person hasn't replied yet. I told the person who replied immediately that if the other person didn't beat their offer soon, I would sell the book to them.

However, now here is the meat of this question, they just asked me:

"So if the other person passes, did you want $50 or $60?"

How can I explain politely that, since they said they would pay $60, I would prefer for them to honour that pledge? (It doesn't seem fair to the other person that I would take the $50 anyway.... or maybe I am just greedy ....)

1
source | link