6

Note: I considered asking this at Mi Yodeya but it is really about how to deal with people and culture, more than about Judaism as a religion.

We will have Jewish friends (from the US) staying at our place for a week or so (adults and children 3 to 14 yo). We live in France and are atheists but want them to feel "like at home", especially on the religious side.

Are there any commonly agreed upon rules in the Jewish community about how to deal with the (as far as I can tell) strict religious rules? Specifically the ones I was thinking about are

  • Kosher food: we will get rid of the obviously non-kosher food (such as pork) but we can easily miss the more obscure ones (obscure as not universally known outside of the Jewish communities)
  • Shabbat: switching on lights for instance is a problem - we are likely going to forget to switch them on or off. There are probably other "practical life oriented" things as this one we are not aware of.
  • Shabbat again: is it OK to watch the ceremony (I am curious how it is in real life)?

To be clear: if there is a set of rules which someone already thought of I would like to avoid reinventing the wheel. And we will of course ask them gently about these points but want to anticipate the ones which are known.

How do I communicate to my jewish friends that we are already aware of some rules regarding their religious obligations, have made some arrangements and some accommodations, but need their feedback and other specific needs?

  • Hi WoJ, I've edited your OP in order to make it more on-topic and dodge some VTC. Please let us know if the edit is OK with you, and feel free to edit/rollback, thanks. – OldPadawan Feb 26 at 11:17
  • @OldPadawan: it's fine. I tried to make my question as straightforward as possible - being a genuine question in preparation of a visit and knowing how everyone is offended by everything today :) Thanks. – WoJ Feb 26 at 12:21
  • 1
    @WoJ Do you know which branch/denomination of Judaism these friends are part of or have you had conversations before about their religious practice that could give you some hints? I suspect some of the suggestions you are making might already be a bit overkill. – Bryan Krause Feb 26 at 15:47
  • @BryanKrause: no, not yet - we just discussed with my wife today about inviting them and since I am not in touch with Jewish religion practices I wanted to anticipate as much as possible. I will, as mentioned in my question, discuss with them - this is clearly by far the most important part.To give a counterexample: if I was to have Catholics at home, I would know that beside the Sunday mass and no meat on Friday, that would be it in terms of constraints. Having read here and there about Jewish traditions, I know that this may be more complicated. Finally this is a super opportunity to learn. – WoJ Feb 26 at 16:00
  • @WoJ Even that is a bit overkill for Catholics; many wouldn't bother going to mass on Sunday especially when away from their home, meat on Friday only applies during Lent and even so many Catholics don't bother with it. As far as Jewish folk in the US, Jewish Americans are among the most likely groups to be atheist as well. – Bryan Krause Feb 26 at 16:05
9

TL;DR: Reach out to them and explain that you need to work things out with them beforehand.


Note: I'm assuming a Modern Orthodox level of Judaism. This is based on my own experience, as a Modern Orthodox Jew.

How do I communicate to my jewish friends that we are already aware of some rules regarding their religious obligations, have made some arrangements and some accommodations, but need their feedback and other specific needs?
(emphasis added)

I'd like to start with saying one thing: Don't just do something based on your knowledge of the religion without consulting them first.

You mention that you'll be getting rid of "obvious non-kosher foods". Okay; that's great. But do you need to do that? You can eat the food. It's not a problem for it to be in the same house as them; they simply can't benefit from it themselves. It's not like they can even eat from your dishes in any case; you'll need to either get new dishes, have your friends tovel them (immerse them ritually in natural running water), and keep them separate from your regular dishes... or just buy disposable plates for the time that they're there.
(They also can't eat any of your food; unless it's explicitly got a hechsher (sign of Kashrut), they can't eat it anyway, fruits and vegetables aside (which have their own issues that I can't get into).)

You need to reach out to them about this. Figure out together what you're doing about utensils, plates, etc, as well as figuring out how they're going to find food to eat. Do not assume that your own preparations are sufficient.

The other thing you mentioned was Shabbat. This is a really tricky situation, because of the sheer number of things to take into account. Your town may or may not have an eruv - a string that runs around the entire town that allows Jews to carry items through the street - so they may or may not be able to carry anything in their pockets on Shabbat. Bear in mind that they also can't walk more than ~1.2km away from the city in each direction on Shabbat and that they can't use transportation.

Again, reach out to both your guests and the local Jewish residents. Inquire about the eruv... but make sure that you don't make any plans around this without consulting your guests first.

There are other things to consider as well - such as the fact that they're not allowed to explicitly ask you to do something that they can't do themselves on Shabat unless it's for the good of an entire community. After a meat meal, they have to wait 6 hours before eating dairy. There are prayers in the morning, afternoon, and night. There are many more such examples.

These are just a few things.

The point of this was to illustrate that you can't rely on your own assumptions and research. Don't assume that whatever precautions you took are good enough without discussing it with them.


I assure you, if you just call them, state honestly that you need to talk to them about the trip, and have a discussion about what they need - they'll both appreciate it, you'll learn a lot, and you can both plan ahead for the trip to make sure that it's enjoyable. Be honest and open to ideas, and most importantly, respect what they say if they say that something won't be possible or that they need to do something at a certain time. Trust their judgement over yours.

Also, as @DavidK points out in the comments, some people don't adhere as strictly to certain laws. It's entirely possible that you'll be planning for something completely unnecessary if you try to make preparations without consulting them. You have to work with them to figure out what you need to make accommodations for and what you don't need to adjust for.

Doing this as early as possible is key, so that there's time to make any adjustments or preparations necessary - such as reaching out to the local communities about where to buy kosher food, for instance.

Reach out early, ask them to help you prepare for their visit, and listen to what they say.

  • 5
    I would also add the importance of talking to the guests because there's a good chance that they need to do far less than religious rules dictate. Many (if not most) Jews in the US do not keep strict Kosher and Shabbat rules, especially in situations where doing so would be an imposition on their hosts. – David K Feb 26 at 13:06
  • @DavidK: yes. I commented about that below the question, in response to Bryan's comment. – WoJ Feb 26 at 16:02
  • Thanks Arwen for the very interesting points (most of them I was indeed discovering as i was reading your answer) – WoJ Feb 26 at 16:03

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.