How to respond to a joke insult that was unintentionally really offensive?

Question

As friends you often throw (what you believe to be) harmless insults at each other, nothing meant to hurt each other's feelings just something to get a laugh out of each other. Typically when my friends joke around and insult each other I just laugh, and laugh too when they do it to me.

However on rare occasions they will often make a joke or insult that actually offends me and hurts, I usually laugh it off in these situations, but is this the right thing to do? I don't want to try and tell them to stop completely as there's no trend into what does and doesn't genuinely offend me, and I would feel a if I was being unfair if I just asked them to stop all together (besides I enjoy it usually). So what's the best way to react to a joke about you that genuinely offended/hurt you unintentionally.

Answer 1

I certainly "traded barbs" with my friends when I was younger and my brothers and I still take jabs at each other.

Of course there are times when things go too far and the recommended way to deal with it will largely depend on how your circle​ responds when told they've overstepped.

My circle of friends was particularly harsh, and anything that really got to someone was carefully remembered, catalogue​d, and hammered upon at every opportunity till you became more or less desensitized to the topic. So... If your friends are like that, don't let on that it bothers you. Roll with it and redirect with a more humorous jab.

If your circle of friends is a little more reasonable, it may be worth trying to mention that it was a low blow in a humorous way:

Whoa... That was too far, almost as far as insert retaliatory comment here

Or if they're actually reasonable:

Not cool, don't talk about specific sensitive thing,
Then insert next retaliatory comment

In any case, moving back to bouncing jokes/insults directly sends the signal that it was just the particular comment that was offensive, not the activity as a whole.

Answer 2

Been there, done that.

I handled it by rolling with the punches in public, and then talking one on one to the guy who had crossed the line, asking him "not to go there again", because I found it seriously insulting and it made me very uncomfortable.

If the offender is a friend and reasonably serious, this should work for you.

But you must know who you're dealing with. Some people are nasty and cruel, and if you let them know something gets under your skin, they'll double down on it, just because they can.

Answer 3

The one tried and true method for talking trash with your buddies is to OWN THE INSULTS THROWN AT YOU. It sounds strange, but if you own the insult they threw at you, even elaborate on it and make it your own joke, nobody can hurt you. They will eventually have to abandon the joke all together.

For example:

Friend A sends a picture of him eating a banana at a cafe with some friends in our group chat. Friend B cracks a joke about the banana and a sexual act. Friend A agrees, but says he wishes the banana was a bit bigger. Everyone laughs and moves on.

Now if friend A got defensive that would be game over. "No way guys, I don't like bananas like that!" That's the time everyone else in the group chat would jump on him for the killing blows.

If you genuinely think your friends are trying to hurt you, they probably aren't your friends. Otherwise, roll with the punches!