12

My grandfather had become ill last month and it became clear he probably wouldn't recover. One day, my mother came to me and told me that he had died in peace and that there would be a funeral next Thursday. I didn't feel moved or surprised by this. How was I supposed to react?

4
  • I'm very sorry for your loss. Can you specify what you mean by "react"? Are you referring specifically to the situation with your mother, or to your actions in general?
    – HDE 226868
    Jul 11 '17 at 22:16
  • @HDE226868 I'd like to see a universal answer, thank you.
    – foggy
    Jul 12 '17 at 5:19
  • 1
    @foggy There isn't much of a thing called a "Universal answer". If you'd like to see why, please read Globalisation and intersubjective communication and Related Answers: Why your Pakistani answer won't always work for India. "Universal" questions are frowned upon here, and make broad questions that attract answers that can't be measured and compared to each other. Please edit the question to be more specific with your exact social and cultural situation.
    – Zizouz212
    Aug 7 '17 at 20:07
  • Just say 'That's too bad' and ask your mother how she is feeling. If she isn't feeling well console her. You don't need to feel anything yourself.
    – Mars
    Jan 8 '18 at 5:29
12

Contrary to what some people will say, the way you are supposed to react is according to how you feel about it. It's not proper to react one way, and improper to react another way. Your reactions are based on your feelings, not on the feelings other have, or think you should have.

How you should behave is a different concept, and one that is culturally variable. Using the tag for Europe does help with that some, though it can vary even in that "region". Family norms will also be a factor.

In general, it's likely to be appreciated by others who have a stronger reaction to the death if you can be helpful and supportive of them at this time. Be there as a good listener when someone wants to express their sorrow at his passing, and provide earnest good will to them. Remember to speak well of him, and his actions in life, even if you have negative thoughts or memories about him. Find things that you can say, that are honest and truthful about him. Such as "I will miss him," or "I enjoyed visiting him." Don't encourage others if they have negative comments, but don't judge them for such if they do express them. You have lost any further opportunities to be with him, so there is something gone from your life as much as from theirs. Recognising that will help you relate to others, and help them when they need it.

Help those most affected, especially his wife and children, by quietly doing things that they may forget to do. Simple things such as pet care and household maintenance can easily be neglected by those in mourning. The more others are suffering and adrift at this time, the more helpful it will be if you are a stable point that they can rely upon.

Find some references for the stages of grief, such as this one, to read, so that you can understand some of how others may feel, and behave.

2
  • 3
    "the way you are supposed to react is according to how you feel about it." I think OP wrote "react" in the meaning of something like immediate response, not in the meaning of inner feelings or something. Like "X died" – "Oh, wow, that's sad" (or something like that). And there are proper and improper ways to react.
    – Alissa
    Jul 11 '17 at 14:05
  • 1
    I'd add that, if one does not have anything nice to say about the deceased, then one should say nothing at all. It's not the right moment.
    – Ramon Melo
    Jul 14 '17 at 20:24
1

People want to see that you consider his death to be a loss. So I suppose that the first thing you should say is something about how sad it is that he has die. When you do this, you want to make sure that you say something personal ie. "I will miss him", rather than something impersonal, "Death is always sad" lest it come off as robotic. After that, you should ask about the other person as 1) it shows that you care about them 2) it removes the focus away from you and your lack of feelings. It is also valid to ask for some time by yourself, which would have given you more time to figure out how you should have acted.

0

I would say that people have no business wondering about your emotional state or grieving process. However, make sure you recognize that this death affected people differently, and act appropriately respectful.

When my grandfather died, I felt similarly. However, my mom was crushed, and I'm afraid I came across as a little insensitive to her and her siblings. If I could go back, I would take the time to sincerely tell everyone "I'm sorry for your loss."

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.